Suing Your Landlord for Repairs

If your landlord is failing to make serious repairs in your apartment, you may be able to take them to court using the Tenant Dignity and Safe Housing Act (TDSHA) — also known as a “7-D Receivership” case.

Through this law (that UTA helped draft), tenants can ask the court to:

  • Order repairs
  • Reduce rent (rent abatement)
  • Award financial compensation
  • And more, depending on what the court allows

Who Can File a 7-D Case?

  • You must currently live in the apartment you are suing for.
  • The repair issues must still be ongoing.
  • You cannot sue for problems that were already fixed, or for a unit you’ve already moved out of.

How to File a 7-D Case

  1. Fill out the court forms
    You’ll need to complete two documents: the Notice of Petition and the Petition.
    Forms are available here: [Insert Link to Forms – we can link directly if you provide it].
  2. Notarize the Petition page
    A notary public must witness your signature on the Petition.
  3. File the forms at your local city court
    Bring your completed paperwork to the courthouse.
    There is typically a filing fee around $45. Can’t afford the fee?
    Ask the court for a fee waiver by completing a short form. This allows your case to proceed without payment.
  4. Serve the landlord
    After filing, you must make sure your landlord is officially notified (“served”). You can:
    • Have a disinterested third party serve them in person, OR
    • Send the court papers via certified mail

Need Help?

United Tenants of Albany (UTA) can help you:

  • Gather documentation
  • Understand your rights
  • Navigate the court process

Contact us today if you’re considering a 7-D claim or need support preparing your case.

Utility Issues

When Can Utilities Be Shut Off?

Utility companies must follow strict timelines before terminating service:

  • No action can be taken until a bill is 20 days past due.
  • Then, the company must issue a final notice at least 15 days before shutoff.
  • This means the earliest a shutoff can legally happen is 35 days after the due date.
  • Shutoffs can only happen Monday–Thursday, between 8 AM and 4 PM.
  • Shutoffs cannot happen on:
    • Fridays,
    • Holidays,
    • Days when the utility company’s main office is closed, or
    • During the two weeks around Christmas and New Year’s.

If your shutoff didn’t follow these rules, contact the NYS Public Service Commission to report a violation.


Deferred Payment Agreements (DPA)

If you’re behind on your utility bills, you can request a Deferred Payment Agreement (DPA):

  • DPAs allow you to pay back what you owe over time.
  • They must reflect your actual financial situation — down payments can be as low as $0, and monthly payments as low as $10.
  • The agreement must be signed by both you and the utility provider.

If your financial situation changes, contact the utility immediately to renegotiate the DPA. You may need to provide documentation of your changed circumstances.


Shared Metering

If more than one unit shares a utility meter:

  • The Shared Meter Law requires the owner to pay for the service, or to separate the meters.
  • Tenants should not be charged for utilities used by others.

Need Help?

Contact the Public Utility Law Project (PULP) for free support:
📞 Hotline: 877-669-2572
📧 Email: info@utilityproject.org

Tenants in Foreclosure

Tenants living in properties that are in foreclosure—either because the landlord has defaulted on the mortgage or failed to pay taxes—retain rights and protections under both federal and local laws. These protections differ depending on the type of foreclosure.


1. Mortgage Foreclosure

Even if a property goes into mortgage foreclosure, tenants generally have the right to remain in their homes:

  • Lease-holding tenants can stay for the remainder of their lease, even after a foreclosure sale, unless the new owner intends to move in as their primary residence.
  • Tenants without a lease are entitled to at least 90 days’ notice before eviction.

Typical Timeline of a Mortgage Foreclosure:

  1. The landlord (borrower) becomes delinquent and receives a 90-day pre-foreclosure notice from the bank or lender.
  2. A foreclosure lawsuit begins.
  3. The bank serves a Summons and Complaint to the landlord and must also notify tenants. This usually comes in a large legal packet.
  4. The landlord may:
    • Respond or request a settlement conference,
    • Refinance or negotiate a resolution, or
    • Ignore the notice (often the case with absentee landlords).
  5. If unresolved, the lender seeks a Judgment of Foreclosure and Sale.
  6. A foreclosure auction takes place, and either the bank or a third party becomes the new owner.
  7. The new owner must show tenants the deed proving they own the property.

The mortgage foreclosure process typically takes about a year from start to finish.

Common Tenant Defenses in Foreclosure Evictions:

  • The new owner did not serve proper 90-day notice;
  • The new owner filed for eviction too early;
  • The deed was never shown to the tenant;
  • The Notice to Quit was defective or not served properly.

“Cash for Keys” Agreements

In some foreclosure situations, especially when a new buyer wants the property vacant, tenants may be offered money to move voluntarily. This is often called “Cash for Keys.”

Typical Offers:
  • $5,000 for moving out within 60 days
  • $2,500 for moving out within 30 days
  • $1,500 for moving out within 15 days
  • If the tenant does not move within the agreed timeframe, they still retain their 90-day right to stay, but will not receive the payment.
  • If you have a lease and intend to stay beyond 90 days, you should contact the new owner, provide a copy of your lease, and document all communication.

Important Notes About “Cash for Keys” Offers:

  • To receive payment, tenants must sign a written agreement with the bank or new owner outlining the move-out timeline and amount offered.
  • If the tenant does not move out by the agreed deadline, they forfeit the payment, but still retain the right to stay for at least 90 days.
  • If you have a valid lease and plan to remain beyond 90 days, you should:
    • Notify the new owner in writing,
    • Provide a copy of your lease, and
    • Keep a record of all communications.

2. Tax Foreclosure

Tenant protections are different in the case of tax foreclosure, and in many cases fewer legal safeguards exist.

Key Differences:

  • Tenants are not automatically entitled to stay for 90 days or through the lease term.
  • Tenants are not entitled to a court eviction after the municipality takes title.
  • Once the municipality owns the building, the sheriff may issue a 72-hour notice to vacate.

Typical Tax Foreclosure Timeline:

  1. The landlord fails to pay property taxes.
  2. The municipality mails a notice and petition for foreclosure.
  3. The landlord has about 3 months to pay or respond.
  4. If unpaid, the municipality waits approximately 6 months before taking title.
  5. After title is transferred, tenants receive a 72-hour notice to vacate from the sheriff.

Albany County Practices:

  • Albany County makes efforts to notify tenants months in advance of taking title.
  • No evictions are carried out during “Code Blue” months (when temperatures are dangerously low).
  • The County avoids shelter placements where possible, as they absorb the cost.
  • In some cases, tenants may be offered the opportunity to purchase the property.

Section 8 Tenants

Section 8 is a federal rental assistance program where households use a voucher to subsidize rent in the private market, overseen by a local Public Housing Authority (PHA). The voucher “moves” with the household, meaning the tenant can bring their subsidy to new units. Each household is assigned a Section 8 caseworker who monitors eligibility and compliance.


Applying the Voucher to a Unit

To use a Section 8 Voucher:

  • The unit must pass:
    • A “rent reasonableness” test, and
    • A Section 8 inspection.
  • The landlord can charge rent up to what is considered reasonable for that ZIP code based on HUD’s formula—this may be higher than what most tenants could afford without assistance.
  • The tenant pays up to 30% of their income toward rent; the voucher covers the rest via a direct payment to the landlord.

Household & Income Reporting Rules:

  • Only people approved by the PHA may live in the unit.
  • Household changes must be reported within 10 days.
  • Any change in income must be reported to the Section 8 worker within 10 days.
  • An annual recertification is required.
  • Failure to report changes may result in:
    • Retroactive rent increases;
    • The household being labeled a fraud account;
    • Termination from the program.

Repair Issues & Apartment Conditions

If there are repair or habitability concerns in the unit:

  1. Request an inspection from Section 8.
  2. Also request a local code inspection to document violations.
  3. Let Section 8 complete their process—they may choose to:
    • Withhold their rent portion, putting the apartment into abatement.
    • If issues are not corrected within 30–60 days, the tenant may receive a moving voucher.
      • Tenants must use their moving voucher within the allowed time.
      • If a tenant does not secure a new unit before using all available extensions (maximum of 3), they may lose the voucher.

Inspections:

  • Section 8 units are subject to:
    • Move-in inspection
    • Annual inspection
    • Occasional random quality control inspections
  • If the tenant causes damage, the landlord can charge the tenant, but it is still the landlord’s duty to make the repair.

⚠️ Important note: Tenants who fail to pay their portion of the rent—even when withholding rent due to conditions—risk losing their voucher.


Landlord-Tenant Relationship in Section 8

  • At the beginning of tenancy, landlords must offer a 1-year fixed-term lease.
  • After the first year, both parties may agree to a month-to-month agreement.

Eviction Procedures:

  • A landlord must serve court papers to both the tenant and the Section 8 office.
    • Failure to notify Section 8 may lead to dismissal of the case.
  • Landlords cannot charge more than the approved rent listed in the Housing Assistance Payment (HAP) contract.
    • Unauthorized rent increases or side agreements are usually unenforceable.

Eviction Scenarios:

  • Tenants may be evicted for:
    • Nonpayment of their portion of the rent (can result in loss of voucher).
    • Nonpayment during abatement (when Section 8 is withholding rent), but only within the first six months.
  • Under Spiegel Law, tenants may have a defense against eviction or liability if:
    • The PHA or subsidy provider is withholding payment due to bad conditions.
  • After six months of abatement, if the tenant has not moved, they may:
    • Be liable for all rent owed;
    • Be terminated from the Section 8 program.

Public Housing Tenants

Public housing is usually managed by a local Public Housing Authority (PHA). For example:

  • Albany: Albany Housing Authority (AHA)
  • Troy: Troy Housing Authority

Not all municipalities have PHAs. (e.g., Colonie has no PHA, despite being seven times the size of Watervliet, which does.)


Lease Basics & Income-Based Rent

When tenants enter public housing, they agree to detailed lease terms. Common terms include:

  • Rent is set at 30% of total household income.
  • Only individuals listed on the lease may reside in the unit.
  • New occupants must be approved and added to the lease, with full income disclosure.
  • Unauthorized occupants may result in termination of tenancy.
  • Tenants must report any income changes to the PHA immediately.
  • Failure to recertify income may result in:
    • Retroactive rent charges;
    • Lease termination.
  • Rent adjustments are based on the date of income change notice, not the date income is received.
  • If a tenant loses income, they should immediately request a “hardship rent” review (as low as $0–$50/month in some cases). Delayed notification will likely mean no retroactive adjustments.

Transfers

Tenants may request a transfer by writing to their building manager. If there have been household or family status changes, these must be reported.

  • Emergency Transfers: Only granted when there is an immediate threat to life, health, or safety that cannot be resolved within 24 hours.
  • Non-emergency transfers are handled on a needs-based system.

Lease Violations & Eviction Process

When a tenant is accused of violating their lease, the process generally follows these steps:

  1. Initial written notice of the violation.
  2. Follow-up notice if the issue continues.
  3. Tenant is given the right to request an informal hearing.
    • ⚠️ Important note: This request may need to be submitted in writing, and tenants may not always be notified of this right.
  4. If the tenant disagrees with the outcome of the informal hearing, they may request a formal hearing, also in writing.

Annual Recertification

  • Mandatory for all public housing tenants.
  • Typically, four reminder notices are sent, but tenants should not rely solely on these.
  • Failure to recertify may lead to:
    • Rent being raised to Fair Market Rent, or
    • Eviction proceedings.

Albany Housing Authority (AHA) Specifics

  • Rent is due by the 5th of each month.
  • If rent is paid after the 10th, a $25 late fee applies.
  • AHA court sessions for nonpayment are held once per month.

In Court:

  • Tenants who appear and pay the current month’s rent are typically offered a repayment agreement (6–12 months).
  • Tenants who appear but cannot pay may be given until the end of the month (usually 2 weeks) to catch up.
  • Before entering a repayment plan, tenants may be asked to sign a Confession of Judgment.

⚠️ Important Notes About Confessions of Judgment:

  • Once signed, it is very difficult to contest.
  • Tenants may still request a file review to verify the balance owed.
  • If a repayment agreement is broken, the entire amount becomes due immediately, and an eviction warrant is issued without a return to court.

Maintenance & Repair Charges

  • Maintenance fees are generally listed in the lease.
  • Charges may apply for every service (e.g., changing a lightbulb: $5).
  • If tenants believe a fee is unfair:
    1. First, raise the issue with the site manager.
    2. If unresolved, submit a written request for an informal hearing.
  • If the lease clearly outlines a charge, it is generally considered enforceable.

Fair Housing Rights

United Tenants of Albany is proud to serve as an Emerging Fair Housing Office, working to ensure that tenants and homebuyers understand and exercise their fair housing rights. The information below outlines the protections guaranteed under federal and New York State law, the responsibilities of housing providers, and the steps you can take if you experience housing discrimination.

Protected Characteristics

Federal Law Protects Against Discrimination Based On:
  • Race
  • Color
  • Religion
  • Sex
  • Disability
  • Family Status
  • National Origin
New York State Law Expands Protections To Include:
  • Age
  • Marital Status
  • Military Status
  • Sexual Orientation
  • Gender Identity
  • Source of Income

Prohibited Actions

  • Refusing to sell or rent housing based on any of the protected characteristics
  • Applying different terms or conditions in a sale or rental
  • Advertising with language that expresses a preference, limitation, or discrimination
  • Coercing, threatening, or interfering with anyone exercising their housing rights
  • Retaliating against someone or a group advocating for fair housing

Who Is Prohibited from Discriminating?

  • Owners and landlords
  • Property managers and managing companies
  • Co-op boards and condominium associations
  • Tenants subletting units
  • Real estate brokers and salespersons
  • Employees or agents of any of the above

Protected Sources of Income

You cannot be discriminated against based on how you legally pay for housing. Protected income includes:

  • Child support
  • Alimony or spousal maintenance
  • Foster care subsidies
  • Social Security income
  • Federal, state, or local public assistance
  • Housing assistance (e.g., Section 8 vouchers)
  • Any other lawful source of income

What To Do If You Face Discrimination

Federal Recourse:
  • File a complaint through the Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
  • Or contact HUD’s Office of General Counsel
State Recourse:
  • Contact the Albany Regional Office of the NYS Division of Human Rights 518-474-2705.
Local Recourse:
  • Contact UTA at 518-646-0629
  • Contact the City of Albany Fair Housing Office at 518-807-1998

Reasonable Accommodations for Tenants with Disabilities

Tenants who meet the legal definition of a disability are entitled to reasonable accommodations.

To request an accommodation:

  • Submit the request in writing to the landlord
  • State that you have a disability
  • Explain how the accommodation will help you better access and enjoy your home
  • Include a note from a doctor, therapist, or service provider verifying the need

⚠️ Important Note: Tenants do not need to disclose specific diagnoses or medical histories.

If the requested accommodation is considered unreasonable, the landlord must:

  • Explain why it is being denied, and
  • Offer a reasonable alternative, if available
  • Landlords may require the tenant to pay for the cost of physical modifications
  • In some cases, landlords may also require tenants to place funds in escrow to restore the unit to its original condition when moving out

Emotional Support Animals

Even if a lease prohibits pets, a tenant with a qualifying disability can keep an emotional support animal.

  • A letter from a licensed therapist or physician is typically sufficient

⚠️ Important Note: If you believe you’re being discriminated against, contact United Tenants of Albany (UTA) for support and guidance.

Good Cause Eviction

Good Cause Eviction is a New York State law that only applies in localities that have opted in to the protection. That means your village, town, or city must pass a local law adopting Good Cause before you are covered.


What Good Cause Eviction Does

Good Cause Eviction provides two key protections:

  1. Limits your landlord’s ability to evict you without a valid reason
  2. Caps the amount your landlord can raise your rent within a given year

Where Good Cause Eviction Applies (as of April 23, 2025)

New York City (Brooklyn, Bronx, Manhattan, Queens, Staten Island), City of Albany, City of Beacon, City of Binghamton, City of Ithaca, City of Kingston, City of Poughkeepsie, City of Rochester, City of Hudson, City of Newburgh, Town of Poughkeepsie, Village of Catskill, Village of Croton-on-Hudson, Village of Fishkill, Village of New Paltz, Village of Nyack


1. Lease Renewal Rights – Limited Eviction Grounds

Tenants in good standing have the right to automatic lease renewals. A landlord cannot refuse to renew a lease without one of the following legal reasons:

  • You owe rent
  • You violated the lease
  • You are creating a nuisance
  • You are using the property for illegal activity
  • You are unreasonably denying the landlord access to the unit
  • The landlord or their family needs to move into the unit
  • The landlord plans to demolish the property
  • The landlord plans to remove the unit from the rental market
  • You refuse to accept reasonable changes to the lease

2. Limits on Rent Increases

Under Good Cause Eviction, landlords cannot impose unreasonable rent increases.

Rent increases are capped at:
5% + the local Consumer Price Index (CPI) or 10%, whichever is less.

Example – Albany CPI (as of April 23, 2025): 3.38%

  • Maximum increase allowed: 5% + 3.38% = 8.38%

All eviction claims must go through court. A judge must determine if the landlord’s reason is valid.


Rent Increase Examples

Example A

  • Current Rent: $1,000/month
  • CPI: 3.38%
  • Maximum legal increase: $1,083.80
    (8.38% of $1,000 = $83.80)

Example B

  • Current Rent: $1,000/month
  • CPI: 8% (hypothetical future date)
  • Capped Increase: 10% → $1,100/month
    (Even though 5% + 8% = 13%, the increase is capped at 10%)

Example C

  • Current Rent: $1,000/month
  • CPI: 3.38%
  • Landlord demands: $1,150 (15% increase)
  • Context: Landlord renovated the bathroom and added new appliances
    → This may justify a higher increase, but it must be proven in court. You have the right to challenge it.

Carve Outs for Landlords

Importantly, there are many carve-outs for landlords. Below is a chart to simplify the protection:


What to Do if Your Rent Increase Seems Unreasonable

If your landlord raises your rent beyond the legal limits—or refuses to renew your lease without a valid reason—you may be protected under Good Cause Eviction. Contact United Tenants of Albany immediately to get support.

Residential Occupancy Permits (ROPs)

*Applicable to the City of Albany only*

Residential Occupancy Permits (ROPs) are designed to ensure that rental units are safe and that the City of Albany has up-to-date contact information for property owners in case of emergencies. ROPs are valid for two years.

An ROP is essentially a basic safety inspection. Code enforcement officers check for:

  • Proper placement of smoke and carbon monoxide detectors
  • Safe entry and exit routes
  • Overall cleanliness, safety, and security of the unit

If your unit does not have a valid ROP, your landlord cannot legally evict you for non-payment of rent. You are protected from non-payment evictions until the unit is brought into compliance and a valid ROP is issued.

Important Note: While landlords cannot evict you for non-payment without an ROP, they can sue for “fair use and occupancy” in small claims court to recover some rent.

If your unit does not have an ROP, or you’re unsure, you should:

Landlord and Tenant Responsibilities

As a tenant, you have important rights that protect your safety, privacy, and access to essential services—and you also have responsibilities to help maintain a safe and respectful living environment. This guide outlines what landlords are required to provide and what’s expected from you as a tenant, so you can better navigate your rental experience.


Landlord Responsibilities:

  • Landlords must provide clean and sanitary living conditions in both common areas and individual apartments.
  • In buildings with two or more units, landlords must respect shared public areas.
  • Adequate heat must be provided from October 1 to May 31.
  • Landlords have a duty to maintain the property, including general repairs and utilities.
  • All services to the unit (e.g., water, electricity, gas) must be properly connected.
  • Tenants have a right to privacy, which includes receiving at least 24 hours’ notice before a landlord enters the unit—except in emergencies.
  • Landlords must ensure basic security, including functioning door locks and proper lighting.
  • Reasonable apartment sharing must be allowed for a limited time.
  • Landlords must make reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities, unless doing so would impose an undue financial burden.
  • Landlords may not discriminate against tenants.
  • Lockouts or evictions can only occur with a court order and judgment.
  • If an eviction occurs, landlords must store the tenant’s belongings in a dry and secure location for a reasonable period (typically 30 days).
  • If a tenant moves out before the lease ends, the landlord must make a good-faith effort to re-rent the unit and provide receipts before seeking reimbursement from the tenant for any losses.
  • When a building is sold, the landlord must notify tenants of the new owner’s name and address.
  • The landlord must also transfer any security deposit and prepaid rent to the new owner.

Tenant Responsibilities:

  • Tenants must maintain a clean and safe living environment.
  • Tenants must promptly report needed repairs or any damage beyond normal wear and tear.
  • Rent should be paid within the first five days of each month. Note: Late fees may not exceed $50 or 5% of the monthly rent, whichever is less.
  • Tenants must allow the landlord access to the unit with at least 24 hours’ notice, except in emergencies requiring immediate entry.
  • Apartments should not be overcrowded (generally defined as more than 1.5 people per room).
  • Tenants must follow the lease terms, unless contradicted by state law.
  • Tenants may be required to cover reasonable costs for accommodations related to a disability.
  • If tenants change the locks, they must provide the landlord with a copy of the new keys.
  • Pet deposits may be required, depending on the lease agreement.